While Canadian cities are known for high living standards and social welfare programs, American salaries, especially in fields like tech, healthcare, and law, far outpace Canadian ones. With Canada grappling with skyrocketing living costs and stagnant wage growth, it’s worth examining whether its social benefits justify the widening income gap with the United States. Whenever something bad happens in the U.S., people always want to go up north to Canada; economically, it’s not all that great up here.
In the United States, salaries in industries such as technology, healthcare, and finance are notably higher. According to recent data, a software engineer in Silicon Valley earns an average of $122,000 USD, compared to $83,000 CAD in Canada, highlighting a significant disparity even after accounting for currency differences. Such wage differences are tied to the productivity-focused, high-output economy of the U.S., driven by investment in sectors that experience rapid growth and innovation. Cities like San Francisco, New York, and Austin have become tech hubs where demand for specialized skill sets inflates wages beyond what is feasible in Canada. This disparity also extends to professions like law, where, according to the American Bar Association, the median salary for a lawyer in the U.S. is $126,000 USD—almost double that of a Canadian counterpart, which averages $80,000 CAD. The U.S. economy’s structural support, bolstered by venture capital and public-private partnerships, contributes significantly to higher wage ceilings, something Canada struggles to parallel. Being a lawyer in Canada is like being the CEO of a T-shirt printing company; yeah, you’re a lawyer, but why are you still living with five roommates?
Maybe it’s all the free healthcare? Canada’s social safety net, with universal healthcare as a cornerstone, remains a compelling feature of its economic model. Universal healthcare saves the average Canadian household around $2,000 to $3,000 CAD annually in medical expenses, offering protection against unexpected medical costs that can be catastrophic in the U.S. However, with recent reports highlighting median wait times of 22.6 weeks for elective surgeries, access can be limited. The Fraser Institute’s studies show that prolonged wait times are becoming the norm, leading some Canadians to seek care in the U.S., where it’s faster but costlier. For those in high-earning roles, the trade-off between higher salaries and the cost of U.S. healthcare becomes more favorable, as they can often afford private insurance plans that ensure timely medical attention, diminishing Canada’s relative advantage in social benefits.
High taxation in Canada also complicates the financial landscape. A dual-income household in Canada earning $150,000 CAD faces an effective tax rate of around 28–30% after federal and provincial taxes. In contrast, a similar household in the U.S. may pay closer to 20–22%, depending on the state, allowing for greater disposable income. While Canada’s tax structure funds benefits such as paid parental leave, a family in the U.S. might find that a higher after-tax income permits more flexibility in housing choices and educational investments, particularly for high earners. U.S. policies that allow lower taxes for the wealthy further incentivize migration for professionals in high-paying sectors. Nothing makes you more conservative than getting a little more money.
Housing costs and overall cost of living further amplify the income disparity. For Canadians, homeownership and rent in urban centers like Toronto and Vancouver have reached crisis levels. In 2023, the average home price in Toronto hovered around $1.1 million CAD, making it one of the least affordable cities globally. This has pushed a large segment of the population, even those with high salaries, toward housing insecurity, particularly as wages stagnate relative to rising costs. By comparison, while home prices in cities like San Francisco and New York are also high, the higher average incomes provide a slightly better balance.
The housing affordability crisis in Canada has also been exacerbated by immigration policies that target skilled labor. As immigration has increased, demand has outpaced housing supply, particularly in popular cities, inflating property prices significantly. Between 2015 and 2023, Canada’s immigration rates grew by 8–10% annually, which has stimulated the economy but placed a strain on urban housing. The resulting economic imbalance leads some immigrants, who arrived with high expectations, to either consider moving to less costly regions or leaving Canada altogether to seek better financial stability.
Inflation, too, has sharply impacted Canadians’ cost of living. Rising costs of essentials—groceries, utilities, and housing—are compounded by increased interest rates implemented to curb inflation, making mortgage payments unaffordable for many. In the past year, the Canadian government’s policy response has included raising interest rates to over 5%, yet this has only added to the housing strain by reducing loan accessibility. Canadians increasingly feel the squeeze, as long-term financial planning becomes more challenging. They’re lowering now, but let’s see what happens. I’m pretty sure all the good economists went over to the U.S.
The economic disparity between the U.S. and Canada encompasses more than a simple salary gap. It reflects differences in policy, economic productivity, and social welfare strategies, each influencing the quality of life for professionals. For skilled professionals, especially those in high-demand and well-compensated sectors, American wages and lower taxes may increasingly outweigh the social safety net Canada offers. As Canada contends with rising housing costs and stagnating real wages, the allure of higher income and lower taxes in the U.S. grows stronger. This economic climate suggests that for many Canadians, particularly younger professionals, the American dream may seem more viable, urging them to reassess their future in search of better financial security and opportunities.
I don’t know what the Canadian dream is, but I’m pretty sure this isn’t it.
Body of Knowledge 
Leave a comment